
Picture an apple. Try to envision it in your mind. What does your apple look like? Can you see a clear image, or is it blurry? Is your apple bright red or gray? Perhaps it’s mostly dappled yellow with a flush of pink. Does the stem have a leaf on it? Are there any soft spots? If you are unable to form a clear picture in your mind, you may have aphantasia. It is rare, affecting only about 1% to 4% of the population.
Aphantasia is not a learning disability. It’s not a recognized disability at all. Rather, just as hair can be curly or straight, aphantasia is a natural variation in humans. It occurs in the brain and impacts people’s ability to visualize. Genetics are thought to play a large part in whether a person has aphantasia although some people acquire it because of a traumatic brain injury.
As you might imagine, aphantasia can make writing a bit more challenging for the person who has it. One parent who has aphantasia reached out to IEW and asked about how aphantasia as well as hyperphantasia (the ability to conjure extremely vivid mental images) might impact students learning to write with Structure and Style®. Below is my response to her.
Thank you for contacting us with your question about aphantasia and its effects on the writing process. Certainly, a person with this brain-based difference will process information differently, and it can also make the writing process a bit more challenging. Teaching your students to write using the Structure and Style writing method will benefit not just students with aphantasia but also students with hyperphantasia.
One of the biggest benefits of the Structure and Style method is that it doesn’t expect students to begin by writing from a prompt. These types of “blank brain” writing assignments are especially challenging for students with visualization impediments because they struggle with drawing images in their minds, especially if they are writing about a subject they are unfamiliar with. Instead, IEW provides source texts. These source texts address a broad range of content that crosses the curriculum and offer valuable scaffolding from which students learn to write. The source texts also build content knowledge. Initially, students learn how to write a key word outline. It is from the key word outline that students write their compositions. As they write, they sharpen their thinking skills. Over time students learn a variety of structures that they can call upon to address many types of writing scenarios.
The structural models provide students with a reliable way to organize their writing. They will help a highly creative student to have a framework to work within, which helps to keep the writing focused. For students who have difficulty visualizing, they will literally have a visual model before them to refer to as they learn how to organize their thoughts. The models they learn will be ones they will be able to call upon as they move through their academic years and beyond.
Perhaps the most significant benefit for students with aphantasia is how IEW incorporates style. We encourage teachers and teaching parents to drip in the stylistic techniques using the EZ+1 philosophy, which means the student can insert the technique easily and that it doesn’t sound too awkward at least most of the time before adding the next stylistic technique. The first technique, for example, is the -ly adverb. When you introduce the technique, you will help your students craft a list of possible -ly adverbs that fit within the context of the assignment. You will model how to insert the technique as well. If you can actually model the -ly adverb visually too, that’s icing on the cake! Eventually your students will have a handy list to consult, which will help them insert meaningful style as they write. It will have the additional benefit of expanding their vocabulary and syntax.When students can easily insert an -ly adverb into each paragraph they write, they are ready for you to introduce the next stylistic technique: the who/which clause.
Help your students as much as they need. In fact, you really cannot help them too much. The talk Four Deadly Errors of Teaching Writing is a great resource to consult to learn more about the error of withholding help.
Andrew Pudewa has often mentioned that a student can’t think a thought if the student doesn’t have the words to think it. IEW’s stylistic techniques will help your students cultivate vocabulary so that they can more effectively express themselves. Through the use of source texts, writing key word outlines, learning the structural models, inserting stylistic techniques, and developing word lists, students of all abilities will grow in their writing skills as well as their general knowledge.
by Jennifer Mauser
